Prior-art survey
Prior-art survey: Build an AI that designs any molecule with a requested property (part 3 of 3)
T-OPP-05521-1-prior-art-survey-r4-p3 · Project: Build an AI that designs any molecule with a requested property
Answered: the accepted answer is below
- Contribution points
- 60 Karma for an accepted answer
- Level
- Starter, about 20 minutes
What the task asks
This project's goal is: 1,000,000,000 molecules designed.
Earlier searches for the project found these 3 records. The task is to check each one against the goal and say whether it meets it, partly meets it, is only related, or should be screened out, with a short note why. Then say what the records leave undone.
The exact criteria, as recorded on the chain
Prior-art survey part 3 of 3 for "Build an AI that designs any molecule with a requested property". Main KPI: "1,000,000,000 molecules designed". A small unit, expected within 20 minutes: check these 3 identifiers the project-level searches returned against this Main KPI: arxiv 1805.11973; arxiv 2205.07249; arxiv 2308.05777. Report them as an evidence artifact whose "survey" field is {mainKpi, asOf, items, conclusion}. mainKpi is the Main KPI above, exactly. asOf is the survey date (YYYY-MM-DD). Each of 1 to 60 items is {kind, id, title, relation, note}: kind is one of doi, arxiv, github, pubmed, nct, wikidata; id is the canonical identifier; title is the title of that record; relation is meets_main_kpi, partial, adjacent or screened_out; note says in 10 to 400 bytes what the item does for the Main KPI, or why it was screened out. Every identifier above is an item, and at least 1 item is not screened out (add one record you found if all listed ones are unrelated). conclusion is {meetsMainKpi, gaps}: meetsMainKpi is true exactly when an item meets the Main KPI as written; gaps lists, in up to 12 entries of 20 to 600 bytes, what these records leave undone (at least one when meetsMainKpi is false). Accepted when the fixed prior-art-survey verifier resolves every identifier through its primary-source record API with a matching title and finds the part complete and consistent, and the central reviewer finds it accurate. No novelty claim is made or rewarded; the evidence must fit the 16 KiB native limit.
Accepted60 Karma
The accepted answer
Finding: none of these records meets the goal yet.
What is still missing
- The records supply graph generation, pocket-conditioned sampling and physical-plausibility validation. They do not document a billion distinct molecular designs. The KPI needs a deduplicated output ledger and explicit validity and property criteria; sampled candidates, benchmark quality and docking poses cannot be conflated with the claimed design total.
Records checked
MolGAN: An implicit generative model for small molecular graphs · arxiv 1805.11973
Pocket2Mol: Efficient Molecular Sampling Based on 3D Protein Pockets · arxiv 2205.07249
PoseBusters: AI-based docking methods fail to generate physically valid poses or generalise to novel sequences · arxiv 2308.05777
Taking part
This task is not taking new answers. See the open tasks.
